Carbon steel pans are best known for their durability and tolerance to heat. The pan heats faster than other stainless utensils and has a slick non-stick surface. Steel pans have a lot of benefits but are not ideal for all cooking situations. Thus before purchasing one must check for the downsides along with its features. Carbon steel pans are the same as iron pans, except for the type of material and few features. Steel pans are made up of 99% iron and 1% carbon whereas iron pans are made up of 98% iron and 2% carbon.
The carbon adds strength, thickness, and hardness and makes the pan more malleable and brittle. To increase the durability of the utensils, pans are accompanied by heavy walls. Carbon steel pans with low carbon percentages are comparatively more malleable. The carbon steel pans are used to cooking all kinds of recipes, mixing, roasting, etc. The carbon pans are used in restaurants and households. Steel pans can even be used by non-professionals.
Features of Carbon Steel Pans
- Preheating- One major feature of carbon steel pans is that they should be heated before adding the food to avoid the food sticking to the edge of the walls of the pan. This might also burn the utensil, make cleaning tedious and deteriorate the overall look of the pan.
- Storage- The food should not be stored in carbon steel pans as it affects the quality of the food. The food may react with the metal and the food may turn bad. Not only will the food is affected, but also the quality of the pan.
- Cleaning- Cleaning the surface of the carbon steel pan is quite difficult. You need warm water and a sponge for cleaning but are advised not to use detergent. The water used should not be too hot nor too cold as the extreme temperature can affect the pan. Make sure you remove things with a strong odor from the pan before storing it as the odor may affect the food that’s cooked in the pan. To make this condition better Salt is strongly heated and taken out with the help of an absorbent paper.
- Storage- The pan must be stored in a clean and dry place of minimum depreciation. If not. it will sabotage the quality of the pan. If you store the pan in a damp place, make sure that the pan is kept with extra protection like lubricating with any kind of oil, preferably vegetable oil. This will reduce the reaction between the metal and humid air.
- Care- The lifetime of the pan depends on the quality of care it receives. The user must be aware of preliminary frying and the surface oil that is impregnating. Before using, the pan must be thoroughly cleaned using mild detergent, water, and a sponge. Later, the pan must be heated with vegetable oil and two teaspoons of butter. Once heated high, the label comes out with the heated butter. It is then poured out and then washed thoroughly. The pan is then ready to use.
Advantages of Carbon Steel Pans
- Lightweight and easy handling– Carbon steel pans score here with a weight of 3.4 pounds. It is a lot lighter than iron pans and easier to handle. Its lightweight increases its demand tremendously. Since these are more malleable during the manufacturing process, the walls of the utensil are made thinner and lighter.
- Versatility- In the case of smaller households with a small kitchen and one cupboard, carbon steel pans are a boon because with one carbon steel pan you can cook all kinds of recipes. Baking, sauteing, frying, braising can all be done using a steel pan. Carbon steel pans are highly heating tolerant and so used out of a store, in a giller, or even in an oven. Also, if you don’t wish to waste time cleaning a lot of utensils, carbon steel pans will help you.
- Durable- As mentioned before, carbon steel pans consist of 99% iron and 1% carbon which makes them extremely durable. If stored with proper care, you can have a pan of the age of your grandfather and still as good as new. The thin walls protect the pan from jerks and shocks causing a crack in the utensil. The nonstick characteristic avoids peeling or wearing off of any covering.
- Extremely affordable and safe- This investment can be as low as $50 for an entire lifetime. The price of a steel pan is the same as an iron pan but the benefits and the life is high for carbon steel pans. So with a very stringent budget, you can still buy a professional carbon steel pan. The product is non-toxic, free from chemical coats and pigments. So no wear off making it perfect for use.
- High heat tolerance and heats fast- Another major feature of carbon steel pans is that they heat up fast. Carbon Steel pans heat up in all kinds of environments quickly making them easier to use. This makes it super desirable for restaurants that look for speed in cooking. The heat tolerance of carbon steel pans is useful while one is cooking steak, burgers, etc. that requires high heat without the item being burnt. These pans do not burn even if kept on stoves or ovens for a little too long. Another noticeable factor is that since it heats up quickly, one can cook fast and enjoy eating for longer. Wouldn’t it be amazing if you could have those five extra minutes for eating?
Disadvantages of Carbon Steel Pan
- Rusting and discoloration- It is a known fact that carbon steel pans are more prone to rusting and discoloration as there is no chemical coating or any other pigmentation to protect them from reacting with atmospheric moisture. The rusting may also occur because of the lack of corrosion-resistant chromium. The absence of this allows oxygen to bond with the metal creating rust and blotch.
- Hot handles- Another disadvantage is that carbon steel pans come with hot handles as they are hollow and connected to the part of the pan that endures most heat. This design tends to concentrate heat and the handle becomes extremely hot which is dangerous when cooking on a stove with a high flame. The intensity of the flame will determine the amount of heat of the handles. In case you are cooking in an oven the handle will turn out to be hot no matter what the temperature is.
- Reacts with acidic food- Despite its versatility, carbon steel pans react with acidic food like tomatoes, lemon juice, and wine sauces. A drop of lemon juice or a tablespoon of vinegar will not ruin your pan but long exposure to highly acidic items might lead to wearing off of the surface. So as you cook something acidic in the pan, quickly transfer the food item to a different container and wash off the pan well.
- Uneven heat distribution- In carbon steel pans, the heat distribution is uneven as the pans are made up of thin materials which hold up less amount of heat to distribute. While cooking you might find that it is extremely hot in the middle while the walls are comparatively less hot.
- Sticky surface- It might be surprising that carbon steel pans tend to have a sticky surface which can be prevented by taking good care of the pan and using lubricants like vegetable oil and butter. This can also be prevented by restraining the use of sharp items while cooking in the pan.
Features to Look for While Buying A Carbon Steel Pan
- The thickness of the pan- When you are trying to find the best carbon steel pan it is important to look for the right thickness of the pan. The thickness of any utensils is measured in gauge or mils and the ideal carbon steel pan should be as thick as 10 gauge. The right thickness of the pan will ideally cook your food and you will be able to enjoy the exotic experience of cooking and the ultimate pleasure of eating it.
- Panhandle- Before buying a carbon steel pan always check that the handle is covered with an insulator. It is a known fact that the handles of the pan turn to be hot during the process of cooking. So the buyer must make sure that the handle is made up of aluminum, or even cool handles are great options. Silicon handles do not have the property of resisting heat, so users must wear mittens to keep themselves safe from any kind of nasty burn.
- Riveted and Rivetless Frying Pans- The riveted handles are permanently fixed to the pan. In pans like this, there is no hassle of fixing the loose screws now and then. The major drawback in such pans is that special care must be taken to keep the bacteria at bay. In a rivetless flying pan, the walls of the pan are smooth and easy for cooking. It also eliminates the collection of bacteria at the nooks and corners of the pan. Rivetless frying carbon steel pans are often considered over riveted pans.
- Nonstick and natural frying pan- Non-stick pans help in preventing the food from sticking at the surface of the pan. It also offers easier and faster cleaning as there is no food stuck to the surface of the pan. Non-stick pans are preferred by new era health-conscious people who prefer their food with less oil or fat as food can be cooked with less or sometimes even no oil. However, the non-stick pans are often subject to scratches from cooking or cleaning which makes the appearance of the pan less appealing. One must also note that the non-stick pans must not be used while cooking at a very high temperature. Natural finish pans, on the other hand, are comparatively economical. It is also the best kind of pan for a searing price. However, it lacks the benefits of non-stick pans.
Top 13 Best Carbon Steel Pans
Features
- Shape– The pan has a stable shape that makes it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items. The height of the wall of this product is 3.9 inches.
- High-quality material- The pan is made up of premium quality material and heavy-duty. It has 15 gauge carbon steel making it of absolutely high quality. The large and smoothly made wooden handle gives a strong and comfortable grip while the user is cooking. This leads to a safe and good cooking experience.
- Hammered wok- The carbon steel pan is made with the utmost intricate design. The screws and handles are tightly fixed and welded.
Advantages
- Easy handling and storage- The carbon steel is big enough but not too large. The wooden handle and lightweight make it easier to carry and more around. The product comes with a box that can be used for easy storage.
- Genuine taste- The carbon steel pan is free of any chemical coating. So now, using this product the user can enjoy the genuine flavor of their preferable cuisine. You can cook Chinese, Korean, Indian, and even Japanese cuisine. The 14-inch work at the bottom of the pan is made essentially so that the food cooked can still have a juicy flavor and added crunch.
- Versatility- In addition to cooking all you can think of, the pan excels in cooking all kinds of traditional snacks and meals. The pan supports deep-frying, braising, etc.
Disadvantages
- Maintenance- Like any other utensil at your home this cookware also requires proper maintenance. It comes with a 15-page handbook with all the details about the pan. It contains information about maintenance and a description of the pan.
- Shallow- Customers complain that the pan is shallow and should have been deeper to fulfill all that it promises. If you have a joint family and are looking forward to cooking in abundance, then this product might not be enough to fulfill your purpose.
De Buyer 22303 11″ Mineral B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan
Features
- Arrives with the beeswax-The product comes coated with beeswax to protect it from all kinds of shocks and contaminations. The beeswax protects the metal and works against oxidation.
- Composition- The product is made up of 99% iron and 1% carbon and is 100% natural. This makes the product safe for use. The absence of chemicals and pigmentation prevents all kinds of toxicity that could have touched your food.
- Thickness- The product has a stable shape and is 2.5 or 3mm thick making it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items.
Advantages
- Ergonomic handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
- Even distribution of heat- Since the pan is flat, the heat is evenly distributed and the food is cooked with the right heat. The natural juice in the vegetables remain in it and a crunch is added
Disadvantages
- No heat insulator- since the handle is not insulated it gets extremely hot while cooking on a high flame. One must make sure that if one is cooking on a high flame then they must wear mittens and be careful of the heat.
- Requires Maintenance- like any other utensil at your home this cookware also requires proper maintenance. It comes with a 15-page handbook with all the details about the pan. It contains information about maintenance and a description of the pan.
Features
- Anatomy- The pan is made up of heavy gauge 4mm and stainless steel. The heat transfer is fast and spreads evenly and smoothly. The heat transfer is faster than a non-stick pan. The no-hole bottom of the pan is designed to avoid all kinds of scratching and discomfort.
- Unraveled- The above pan is non-stick and allows you to flip all kinds of food with greater ease as compared to any other kind of original non-stick pan. This can be done at home all the while getting restaurant-quality food.
- Glass lid- The glass that comes with the pan speeds up the cooking process. It also gives you a direct view of how the food is looking while being cooked. The lid minimizes the splatter and minimizes mess.
Advantages
- Non-stick- The pan is non-stick and therefore food can be cooked with a minimum amount of vegetable oil. This acts as a positive factor for health-conscious buyers and their ill family members.
- Suitable for all stoves- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
Disadvantages
- No heat insulator- since the handle is not insulated it gets extremely hot while cooking on a high flame. One must make sure that if one is cooking on a high flame then they must wear mittens and be careful of the heat.
- Less durability- If proper care and maintenance are not done then the pan may wear off easily. The life of this pan might be reduced if acidic food is kept in it for a prolonged period. The user must make sure that acidic food is cooked in it, and the pan is washed immediately.
Merten & Storck Carbon Steel Black Frying Pan
Features
- Silicone handle- The pan has a silicone handle and also a silicone coating. The buyer needs to wash off the coating and do proper seasoning before starting to cook in this pan.
- Gas stove compatibility- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
- Shape and depth- The product have a stable shape that makes it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items. The item is 2 inches deep.
Advantages
- Lightweight- The pan is extremely light in weight and so it is easy for the user to carry it from the cupboard to the kitchen. It is so light that even children can use it with ease. Its lightweight helps it to heat up quickly and distribute the heat evenly.
- Non-stick- The pan is non-stick and therefore food can be cooked with a minimum amount of vegetable oil. This acts as a positive factor for health-conscious buyers and their ill family members.
- Easy to clean– Since the pan has a smooth surface and smooth walls, cleaning becomes easy. The user can simply use soap and water and clean it with a porous sponge.
Disadvantages
- Wears off quickly- The users often complain that the patches of the pan come off after a few uses. This happens when the seasoning is not done properly.
- Overpriced- The product is said to be overpriced given its features and benefits. There is a general notion among the users that they can buy better pans at lower prices.
AmazonBasics Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet Pan
Features
- Anatomy- The pan is made up of 15 inches cast iron skillet and stainless steel. The heat transfer is fast and spreads evenly and smoothly. The heat transfer is faster than a non-stick pan. The no-hole bottom of the pan is designed to avoid all kinds of scratching and discomfort.
- Heavy duty- The pan is made up of good quality material keeping in mind that it can undergo high heat and have optimal heat retention. It can be used for a very long period without any effect on the quality of the pan.
Advantages
- Long handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines. It also ensures a steady and secure hold.
- Heat distribution– The shape of the pan ensures proper even heat distribution. This helps in the even cooking of food such that it retains moisture but also adds crunch.
- Easy care- Since the pan has a smooth surface and smooth walls, cleaning becomes easy. The user can simply use soap and water and clean it with a porous sponge.
Disadvantages
- Bulky- The pan is big and does not have a very smooth surface. This makes it difficult for the user to carry it from the cupboard to the kitchen. It is so large that it becomes tedious for the children in the house to use it.
Lodge CRS12 12-Inch Diameter Seasoned Steel Skillet
Features
- Size- The product is made up of 12 gauge carbon steel. The product has a stable shape that makes it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items.
- Steel Reverted Handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
Advantages
- Multifunctional Cookware- It is the right product to use for sauteing, baking, roasting, simmering, frying, and braising. The surface of the pan is safe to use even with a knife, fork, and spatula.
- Compatible- The product is compatible with different kinds of heat sources. It can be used on a professional gas stove and campfires making it versatile. The steel pan also maintains a low temperature, saving the food from burning.
Disadvantages
- Unstable shape- Since the pan is compatible with all heat sources, it might sometimes tend to have an unstable or dented shape.
- Less durability- If proper care and maintenance are not done then the pan may wear off easily. The life of this pan might be reduced if acidic food is kept in it for a prolonged period. The user must make sure that acidic food is cooked in it, and the pan is washed immediately.
Lodge Manufacturing Company Carbon Steel Skillet
Features
- Material- It is a carbon steel skillet 8 inches deep made up of 99 percent iron and 1 percent carbon. This might make the skillet malleable but extremely efficient. It is constructed of 12 gauge carbon steel and has 2 welded handles to provide a good grip.
- Steel reverted handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
Advantages
- Gas stove compatibility- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
- Shape and depth- The product have a stable shape that makes it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items. The item is 1.5 inches deep.
Disadvantages
- Bulky- The pan is big and does not have a very smooth surface. This makes it difficult for the user to carry it from the cupboard to the kitchen. It is so large that it becomes tedious for the children in the house to use it.
Carbon Steel Wok For Electric, Induction and Gas Stoves
Features
- Shape and size- The product has a 12.5-inch diameter and a flat bottom which makes it suitable for distributing the heat evenly. It can be used on a stove or an induction glass top or even on electric coils.
- Printed hammer texture– The lid has an extremely gorgeous texture which gives it an appealing royal look to the users. There is no coating on this material however, seasoning is required.
- Original flat bottom wok- a flat bottom that makes it suitable for distributing the heat evenly. It can be used on a stove or an induction glass top or even on electric coils.
Advantages
- Multifunctional cookware- It is the right product to use for sauteing, baking, roasting, simmering, frying, and braising. The surface of the pan is safe to use even with a knife, fork, and spatula
- Heat distribution– The shape of the pan ensures proper even heat distribution. This helps in the even cooking of food such that it retains moisture but also adds crunch.
Disadvantages
- Requires Maintenance- like any other utensil at your home this cookware also requires proper maintenance. It comes with a 15-page handbook with all the details about the pan. It contains information about maintenance and a description of the pan.
- Wears off quickly- The users often complain that the patches of the pan come off after a few uses. This happens when the seasoning is not done properly.
Tamagoyaki Japanese Omelette Pan /Egg Pan
Features
- Material- It is made of carbon steel and plastic. It had a hard anodized coating that made it non- stick. Thus it can be used to cook with less vegetable oil.
- Insulated handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
Advantages
- Appealing look- The users often appreciate the overall look of the product. This item can be used as a gift material to your near and dear ones. It is a perfect gift for children interested in cooking and who are learning to do so.
- Even heat distribution- The shape of the pan ensures proper even heat distribution. This helps in the even cooking of food such that it retains moisture but also adds crunch.
Disadvantages
- Small in size- The item is very small in size and is perfect for DIY products but it is not very useful in actual kitchens. However, if food is to be made in small batches then it will not act as a disadvantage.
Features
- Steel reverted handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
- Titanium coated interior- Its interior is coated with titanium giving it extra resilience given the food a beautiful crisp and easy cleaning feature.
Advantages
- Durable and comfortable- The item is very long-lasting and durable. It is often considered a lifetime investment. They also have riveted stainless steel handles making them very comfortable to use. The silicone grip assures secure and comfortable use.
- Multifunctional cookware- It is the right product to use for sauteing, baking, roasting, simmering, frying, and braising. The surface of the pan is safe to use even with a knife, fork, and spatula
Disadvantages
- Requires Maintenance- like any other utensil at your home this cookware also requires proper maintenance. It comes with a 15-page handbook with all the details about the pan. It contains information about maintenance and a description of the pan.
- Less durability- If proper care and maintenance are not done then the pan may wear off easily. The life of this pan might be reduced if acidic food is kept in it for a prolonged period. The user must make sure that acidic food is cooked in it, and the pan is washed immediately.
Features
- Contoured handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
- Gas stove compatibility- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
- Shallow depth- Shallow depth and layered sides make it easier for the user to flip the food. This feature also allows him to plate delicate food like pancakes, fried eggs, fried fish, etc. beautifully.
Advantages
- Worth the money- The pan is easy to use, clean, and store which makes it worth the money. It is durable and is a once-in-a-lifetime investment. They also have riveted stainless steel handles making them very comfortable to use. The silicone grip assures secure and comfortable use.
- Multifunctional cookware- It is the right product to use for sauteing, baking, roasting, simmering, frying, and braising. The surface of the pan is safe to use even with a knife, fork, and spatula
Disadvantages
- No heat insulator- since the handle is not insulated it gets extremely hot while cooking on a high flame. One must make sure that if one is cooking on a high flame then they must wear mittens and be careful of the heat.
- Shallow- Customers complain that the pan is shallow and should have been deeper to fulfill all that it promises. If you have a joint family and are looking forward to cooking in abundance, then this product might not be enough to fulfill your purpose.
Gotham Steel Nonstick Frying Pan
Features
- Size and shape- It has a diameter of 12.5 inches and is perfect for cooking an ideal family size dinner. It has a lot of ups and can be used in almost every cooking situation like whipping up pancakes, searing steaks, steaming broccoli, as well as grilling burgers.
- Non-stick- The pan is non-stick and therefore food can be cooked with a minimum amount of vegetable oil. This acts as a positive factor for health-conscious buyers and their ill family members.
Advantages
- Gas stove compatibility- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
- Shape and depth- The product have a stable shape that makes it convenient for the user to cook using a stove or an oven. This reduces the risk of disbalance and nasty burns. The shape leads to proper adjustment and evenly cooking of the food. Even cooking means less burning and wastage of food items.
Disadvantages
- Less Durability- If proper care and maintenance are not done then the pan may wear off easily. The life of this pan might be reduced if acidic food is kept in it for a prolonged period. The user must make sure that acidic food is cooked in it, and the pan is washed immediately.
- Difficult to clean- Despite the pan having a smooth surface and smooth walls, cleaning becomes a little difficult. It sometimes takes as much as three soaks to clean.
Mineral B Round Carbon Steel Steak Fry Pan
Features
- Ergonomic handle- The product has a big and comfortable handle which increases the grip and balance of the user. This also marks the pan suitable for making french cuisines.
- Gas stove compatibility- It has a premium quality bottom which allows the pan to be placed stably on all kinds of gas stoves without causing any scratch on your stove. It provides outstanding heat conduction without leaving any burn marks on your pan or your stove
Advantages
- Easy clean- Since the pan has a smooth surface and smooth walls, cleaning becomes easy. The user can simply use soap and water and clean it with a porous sponge.
- Even heat distribution- The shape of the pan ensures proper even heat distribution. This helps in the even cooking of food such that it retains moisture but also adds crunch.
Disadvantages
- No heat insulator- since the handle is not insulated it gets extremely hot while cooking on a high flame. One must make sure that if one is cooking on a high flame then they must wear mittens and be careful of the heat.
- Shallow- Customers complain that the pan is shallow and should have been deeper to fulfill all that it promises. If you have a joint family and are looking forward to cooking in abundance, then this product might not be enough to fulfill your purpose.
Conclusion
From the above list, the following are the best two carbon steel pans-
De Buyer 22303 11″ Mineral B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan and MSMK Frying Pan with lid,
Refer back for more informative articles.
